Oracle Software Cannot Be Used By Blind Texas Employees

Release Date

Oracle Software Cannot Be Used By Blind Texas Employees

National Federation of the Blind Files Suit for Equal Access

Austin, Texas (February 5, 2007): The National Federation of the Blind and three blind Texas employees filed suit today to enforce a provision of Texas law requiring all information technology purchased by the state to be accessible to blind employees.  The suit was brought because the blind cannot use software manufactured by Oracle Systems and used by state employees.

The newly acquired software replaced another software package that had, in large part, been accessible to blind users.

Dr. Marc Maurer, President of the National Federation of the Blind, said: “Access to information technology is critical to success on the job for everyone in the twenty-first century, and this is no less true for the blind than it is for the sighted.  The National Federation of the Blind is committed to improving access to all information technologies, and we will take all steps necessary to do so, including litigation.”

Tommy Craig, President of the National Federation of the Blind of Texas, said: “The state legislature of Texas recognized the need for equal access for the blind by passing a law requiring it, and it is unconscionable that a state agency is violating that law.  The National Federation of the Blind of Texas will not rest until all of the employees of the state of Texas have equal access to all the information they need to function effectively.”

The suit, which names as defendants the directors of the Health and Human Services Commission and the Texas Workforce Commission (the agencies for which the blind employees work) and the state’s acting chief technology officer, arises from the state’s continuing renewal of contracts to purchase Oracle’s human resources software and other products, despite the fact that the software cannot be used by blind Texas employees.  The plaintiffs have asked a Texas court to require the software to be made accessible to the blind and to require that the state discontinue its purchases of inaccessible software.

Blind people access computer software by means of screen access programs, which convert what is on the screen into synthesized speech or allow it to be displayed in Braille.  The Oracle software, which is used by state employees for various human resources tasks, does not provide equal access to blind persons using screen access technology.  For example, blind employees cannot access their pay and leave records, and those in supervisory positions cannot create or review performance evaluations.

Edwin Kunz, one of the blind plaintiffs who directs a rehabilitation center for the blind within the Health and Human Services Commission’s Department of Assistive and Rehabilitative Services, said: “I am unable to review and enter information such as my hours worked and leave taken unless a sighted person helps me to do so.  Even worse, I can’t access critical information about the employees that I supervise without the assistance of a sighted person.  Because I must have sighted assistance for all of these personnel functions, both my privacy and the privacy of my employees are routinely violated.  I’ve complained about the problems with the software, but nothing has been done to fix them.  I hope this lawsuit will spur Oracle to move quickly to correct this problem; otherwise the state will have to purchase human resources software from someone else.”

The plaintiffs are represented by the Baltimore, Maryland firm of Brown, Goldstein & Levy, LLP and Scanlan, Buckle & Young of Austin, Texas.

John G. Paré Jr.
Director of Public Relations
National Federation of the Blind
(410) 659-9314, extension 2330
(410) 913-3912 (Cell)